To Subscribe please click here

Moonstone logo
Investment Indicators - 9 October 2017
In This Week's Newsletter
Rates Review
Investment Rates
Money Market Funds
Top 3 Rates
 
From the Crow's Nest
Qualifications and Execution of Sales – Steps to address competence challenges unlikely to work in practice
 
Your Practice Made Perfect
Stick to the script – Can scripted sales lead to fair outcomes for clients?
NCR smacks BMW - Ordered to repay on-the-road costs
 CMS Annual Report 2016/17– Broker costs slightly up, solvency ratio’s slightly down
 
Regulatory Examinations
Updated schedule
Self-Help Guidelines to make a booking, download your certificate or view results
 
Careers Platform
Are you hiring? Advertise your position on Moonstone’s Career Platform
Featured Positions
 
In Lighter Wyn
So you think you are getting old?
Paul Kruger 2016-10-31
Paul Kruger Author/Editor
 
 
 
 

SuiteBox banner

I'll be more enthusiastic about encouraging thinking outside the box when there's evidence of any thinking going on inside it - Terry Pratchett
 
Please connect with us: www.moonstone.co.za pkruger@moonstoneinfo.com or 021 883 8000

 
Facebook   Twitter   LinkedIn   YouTube  
Distributed to 49450 subscribers.

To advertise with us
click here

 
GTC banner 2017-08-10
What if you could focus on doing what you love - looking after your clients?

Leading Independent Financial Advisory (IFA) practices are using GTC’s Strategic Partner solution to:

   - increase time with clients
   - increase earnings
   - reduce costs

Shouldn’t you too?

Our staff and systems deliver exceptional service, increasing revenues and saving costs and time for you, enabling you to build value for succession.

With offices nationally, we are well-placed to help you.

Call us to discuss a strategic partnership.

t. +27 (0) 10 597 6831
e. info@gtc.co.za
w. www.gtc.co.za

An authorised Financial Services Provider FSP no. 731
Rates Review
Top 3 rates
 1. Secured Investment Rates
Please note that (G) indicates a Guaranteed and (L) a Linked product. In order to understand the difference between guaranteed and linked rates, kindly click here for an explanation.
 R 100 000
 
 
 
     
  Company This Week Last Week
1 1Life (L) 6.840% 6.730%
2 Absa (L) 6.715% 6.597%
3 Assupol (G) 6.190% 6.000%
     
 R 1 000 000
     
     
  Company This Week Last Week
1 1Life (L) 6.840% 6.730%
2 Absa (L) 6.715% 6.597%
3 Assupol (G) 6.630% 6.430%
     
 2. Money Market Funds
  Company This Week Last Week
1 Prescient 7.950% 8.110%
2 Cadiz 7.890% 7.940%
3 Allan Gray 7.820% 7.870%
Please bear in mind that our figures, though based on the actual quotations that you also use, are for information purposes only, and can never replace the official quotation from the product house. In terms of the guarantees, you are requested to clarify the exact extent of such guarantees with the product house prior to advising clients.
Top of Page
From the Crow's Nest
From the Crow's Nest
Qualifications and Execution of Sales
The new Fit and Proper (F&P) requirements due for publication any day now contains reference to a new concept which aims to address a thorny issue, namely the different levels of complexity of products sold to the public.

As pointed out last week, a major problem for the Regulator in terms of FAIS was to establish rules and regulations that could be applied equally to both complex and simpler products.

The first step was to differentiate between what eventually became known as Tier 1 and Tier 2 products. This was achieved by involving the industry to arrive at an acceptable agreement on where complex and less complex products should resort.

The next challenge was to determine the levels of competence required by representatives who advise on the various products.

The initial response was the proposed introduction of “execution of sales only”, which can be defined as an intermediary service performed by a person on the instruction of a client that results in the conclusion of an agreement to buy, sell, deal, invest or disinvest in, replace or vary one or more financial products.

The latest draft proposed outlines new requirements regarding qualifications applicable to all, except the following:
 
(i) a Category I FSP, its key individuals and representatives that are authorised, approved or appointed to render financial services only in respect of the financial products: Long-term Insurance subcategory A and/or Friendly Society Benefits; and
 
(ii) a representative of a Category I FSP that is appointed to perform only the execution of sales in respect of a financial product provided that -
 
  (aa) the representative has a Grade 12 National Certificate or an equivalent qualification;
 
  (bb) the execution of sales is performed –
 
    (aA) in accordance with a script approved by a key individual and the relevant governance structure of the FSP; and
    (aB) under the direct oversight of a key individual who meets the competence requirements for the furnishing of advice in relation to the relevant financial product and whose normal place of work is at the same premises where the execution of sales are performed;
 
  (cc) where the execution of sales is performed by telephone, all conversations with clients are recorded and the recordings are stored and retrievable;
 
  (dd) the FSP has sufficient and adequate controls in place to ensure and to monitor that -
 
    (aA) the representative does not furnish clients with advice; and
    (aB) the sales practices and techniques employed by the representative are not misleading, false, inappropriate to the expected target clients or will not result in unfair outcomes for clients; and
 
  (ee) the FSP on a regular basis –
 
    (aA) reviews the recordings referred to in (cc) and/or monitors the representatives, to ensure that they do not deviate from the script or supplement the script with content not approved as contemplated in (bb);
    (aB) reviews and monitors the adequacy and efficiency of its controls and quality assurance processes in relation to the execution of sales; and
    (aC) reviews the script for appropriateness and compliance with applicable legislation.

Training exemptions

In addition to the above, the “Scripturers” will also be exempt from writing the regulatory exams as well as the new Class of Business and Product Specific training.

In practice, this means that, if you are, for instance, a representative of a FSP that sells derivatives, or collective investment schemes, or retail pension benefits, you are not really required to be knowledgeable about such products, as the script will guide the client to make a decision in which you had no hand in, other than reading it to him. This is construed as NOT providing advice, hence you do not need any of this other knowledge that those electing to provide advice has to have.

Those advising only in respect of Tier 2 products qualify for the same exemption.

At this stage, this crucial document, the “Script”, must be “…approved by a key individual and the relevant governance structure of the FSP” and should be used “…under the direct oversight of a key individual who meets the competence requirements for the furnishing of advice in relation to the relevant financial product and whose normal place of work is at the same premises where the execution of sales are performed.”

This of course sets the table for a feast of “after the event” calamities which flies in the face of the Regulator’s stated intention of being forward-looking, pre-emptive, proactive, outcomes-based etc.

Product providers who consider using this as gap to side-step current qualification requirements should bear in mind that, under the new dispensation, they will be accountable for all unintended consequences following from the actions of their representatives.

Top of Page
Your Practice Made Perfect
Your Practice
Stick to the script
We receive many enquiries from readers about debarments, like this one last week:

The reason why I was debarred was that I helped a customer with a loan application over the phone. I told the customer not to disclose too many expenses as the loan would be declined. That was picked up by the quality control department and led to my debarment.

Production targets is seen as one of the biggest reasons for miss-selling, and most direct marketers, despite blaming commission as the greatest sin on earth, actually do pay “success bonuses” to better producers, which obviously lead to unfair pressure and conflicts of interest, as indicated in the example above.

No doubt, representatives sitting with an “execution of sales only” text in front of them are highly unlikely to stick purely to the script. What do they do when a client asks a question?

“Sorry, I cannot answer that, it is not in the script. Let me refer you to my key individual.”

This is akin to expecting a tied agent (“product supplier agent” in the new parlance) to say to a client: “Sorry, my employer’s product is not as good as that of our main competitor. I suggest you rather approach them.”

What would the average man or woman, whose income is reliant on successful sales, do in such a situation? Obviously, attempt to salvage the sale.

But does it lead to fair outcomes for clients, which is the foundation of market conduct regulation?

Methinks there is still some serious consideration required on whether the implementation of “Execution of Sales only” will bring anything new to the table, or actually contribute to fairer treatment of clients.

It merely perpetuates regulation by exemption, and is anything but pre-emptive.
Top of Page
 
SuiteBox horizontal banner 2017-01-12
 
NCR smacks BMW
Views ‘on-the-road-costs’ as not being in line with prescriptions
On 3 August, we published an article on the National Credit Regulator’s (NCR) media statement, warning vehicle financiers (being registered credit providers) that they will be conducting a compliance monitoring exercise on vehicle licence and registrations fees payable under credit agreements. As part of this compliance monitoring exercise, the NCR obtained credit agreements from various vehicle financiers and reviewed the costs stated in the quotations.

The NCR, in a media statement dated 5 October, announced that they issued a compliance notice to BMW Financial Services (BMW), a registered credit provider, instructing them, amongst others, to refund all consumers whom they charged ‘on-the-road’ costs. According to a Business Day report, BMW intends to challenge the compliance notice by applying to the National Consumer Tribunal for a review.

It may very well be that BMW was chosen to send a message to the industry.

Our understanding of ‘on-the-road’ costs is that it often consists of many different components ranging from ‘licence and registration’ fees to ‘fuelling and delivery’ costs, if not provided for separately. Therefore, the possibility exists that at least a portion of the ‘on-the-road’ costs may be costs that are permitted by the National Credit Act, Act 34 of 2005 (NCA). However, it is important that motor vehicle dealers and financiers ensure that they specify these costs in accordance with the NCA.

This matter is one to follow, as was the ‘club fees’ charged by Edcon, as it emphasises the NCR’s commitment to ensuring that only permitted costs are included in the cost of credit to consumers.

Please click here to download a copy of the media release.

Moonstone employed an NCA Specialist to render NCA compliance services to its clients. As part of these services, we are able to assist you in reviewing your ‘on-the-road-costs’ for compliance with the NCA. Should you have any queries, please contact Gerrit Viviers on 021 883 8000 or by email to gviviers@moonstonecompliance.co.za.
Top of Page
 
MBSE banner
 
CMS Annual Report 2016/17
The Council for Medical Schemes (CMS), regulator of the medical schemes industry, released its Annual Report for 2016-2017 on 5 October, providing a comprehensive report on the status of the private medical schemes industry in South Africa.

Some of the interesting statistics in the report include:

Number of medical schemes and beneficiaries

The total number of medical schemes registered as at 31 December 2016 was 82, down from 83, as a result of the amalgamation of LMS Medical Fund and Bonitas Medical Scheme on 1 October 2016. This figure included a total of 22 open schemes and 60 restricted schemes.

Altogether the 82 schemes had a total subscription of 8.879 million members as at 31 December 2016. The industry experienced a year-on-year increase of 0.78 % in the total number of medical scheme beneficiaries, up from 8.809 million in December 2015. The total number of beneficiaries of restricted schemes increased by 1.39% compared to a 0.30% increase in the beneficiaries of open schemes.

Broker costs

Commissions, service fees and other distribution costs increased by 10.0% from R1.8 billion in 2015 to R2.0 billion in 2016, compared to 5.8% in 2015. Broker costs represented 14.1% of total non-healthcare expenditure in 2016, a slight increase from 13.9% in 2015.

Administration expenditure was the main component of non-healthcare expenditure in 2016, at 84.2%, down from 84.6% in 2015. It accounted for 7.3% of GCI in 2016 (unchanged from 2015).

Net healthcare results and impact on reserves

The net healthcare result for all medical schemes combined reflected a deficit of R2 390.8 million in 2016 (2015: R1 208.5 million deficit). Open schemes incurred a total deficit of R955.7 million (2015: R539.6 million deficit), and restricted schemes generated a combined deficit of R1 435.1 million (2015: R668.9 million deficit). This deterioration is mainly due to the worsening claims ratios of all schemes from 91.4% in 2015 to 92.1% in 2016.

The industry average solvency ratio decreased to 31.6% in 2016 from 32.6% in 2015. The solvency ratio of open schemes decreased by 2.1% to 28.6% in 2016 (2015: 29.2%). Restricted schemes experienced a decrease of 4.5% in their solvency ratio, 35.8% from 37.5% in 2015.

The full Annual Report of the CMS, along with Excel and Pdf Annexures which contains detailed information on medical schemes can be accessed on http://www.medicalschemes.com.
Top of Page
Regulatory Examinations
Regulatory exams banner
2017 Schedule updated
Top of Page
 
Self-Help Guidelines to make a booking, download your certificate or view results
Candidates who wrote with Moonstone can now view their results, make a new booking or update their information on our website: www.faisexam.co.za

Here is what you do:
  1. Click on the Moonstone FAIS Exam website (www.faisexam.co.za)

  2. Click on the second heading: “Update Your Booking/Personal Details/Get results”.

  3. Key in your ID or Passport Number used to register for the exam: click on Send password.

  4. The system will send a password to the e-mail address you provided at registration.

  5. Use this password to log in on the same address as above:
    Type in the password – do not copy and paste.

  6. Click login.

  7. You will then be able to make a booking, download your certificate or view results.

Frequently Asked RE Questions – Answers to questions on REs and preparation material

Email enquiries should be addressed to faisexam@moonstoneinfo.co.za. You can phone us on 021 883 8000 - select option 2 to speak to one of our consultants.
Top of Page
Careers Platform
Are you hiring? Advertise your position on Moonstone’s Career Platform
Careers Platform Packages

•   The Moonstone website - www.moonstone.co.za - enjoys an average of 15 000 visits and approximately 39 000 page views per month.
Moonstone boasts an exclusive newsletter mailing list of over 49000 dedicated financial decision makers who receive 2 newsletters per week.
Our audience is relevant and industry specific: individual and corporate advisors and brokers in the following financial sectors: iInvestment, Risk, Healthcare, Banking, Retirement, and Insurance.


Advertise


Top of Page
 
Featured Positions
  • Wealth Management Consultant: Rockfin, Cape Town - As an independent Financial Advisor your role will be to work closely with clients in their medium- to long-term personal financial planning. This is a client facing, sales and targets driven profession. Please only apply if you have the required insurance sales experience. Read More

  • Wealth Management Consultant: Rockfin, Sandton - We are looking for Financial Advisors to provide private wealth management and financial planning services to individual & corporate clients. Read More

  • Business Development Manager: Sovereign Group, Johannesburg - If you are a Graduate or admitted attorney, a confident public speaker with general company, commercial and trust law and happy to spend 50% of your time out of the office in meetings, selling Sovereign Trust’s services, then Read More

  • Marketing & Events Coordinator: Sovereign Group, Cape Town - The applicant must be a fluent and articulate English and Afrikaans speaker holding an undergraduate degree obtained from a reputable tertiary institution. Applicants with a marketing background will receive preference. Read More

  • Legal/Administration Assistant Position (Half Day): Sovereign Group, Cape Town - The successful applicant will assist two to three lawyers in the office, must have a relevant degree and be fluent and articulate in English and Afrikaans. Read More

  • Financial Advisor: Origin Financial, Cape Town - The core function of the successful candidate is to look for new business and maintain relationships with clients. Must have own car & driver’s licence as well as RE certificate. Read More

Top of Page
In Lighter Wyn
In Lighter Wyn
So you think you are getting old?

Getting old?
 

Jeanne Louise Calment had the longest confirmed human Lifespan on record: 122 years and 164 days. It seems that fate strongly approved of the way Madame Calment lived her life.

Jeanne was born in Arles, France, on 21st February 1875.

When the Eiffel Tower was built, she was 14 year old.

It was at this time that she met Vincent van Gogh. "He was dirty, badly dressed and disagreeable," she recalled in an interview given in 1988.

When she was 85, she took up fencing, and she was still riding her bicycle when she reached 100.

When Jeanne was 114, she starred in a film about her life; at 115 she had an operation on her hip, and at 117 she gave up smoking (having started at the age of 21 in 1896). Apparently, she didn't give it up for health reasons, but because she didn't like having to ask someone to help her light a cigarette once she was becoming almost blind.

In 1965, Jeanne was 90 years old and had no heirs. She signed a deal to sell her apartment to a 47-year-old lawyer called André-François Raffray. He agreed to pay her a monthly sum of 2,500 francs on the condition that he would inherit her apartment after she died.

However, Raffray not only ended up paying Jeanne for 30 years, but died before she did at the age of 77. His widow was legally obliged to continue paying Madam Calment until the end of her days.

Jeanne retained sharp mental faculties.

When she was asked on her 120th birthday what kind of future she expected to have, she replied: "A very short one."

Quotes and rules of life from Jeanne Calment:

"Being young is a state of mind, it doesn't depend on one's body, I'm actually still a young girl; it's just that I haven't looked so good for the past 70 years."

"All babies are beautiful."

"I'm in love with wine."

"Always keep your smile. That's how I explain my long life."

"If you can't change something, don't worry about it."

"I have a huge desire to live and a big appetite, especially for sweets."

"I never wear mascara; I laugh until I cry too often."

"I see badly, I hear badly, and I feel bad, but everything's fine."

"I think I will die of laughter."

"I have legs of iron, but to tell you the truth, they're starting to rust and buckle a bit."

"I took pleasure when I could. I acted clearly and morally and without regret. I'm very lucky."

(At the end of one interview, in response to a journalist who said he hoped they would meet again the following year):

"Why not? You're not that old; you'll still be here."
Top of Page


Moonstone 49000 subscribers banner

Tel: +27 21 883 8000   |   Fax: +27 21 883 8005
info@moonstoneinfo.com
www.moonstone.co.za


P.O. Box 12662, Die Boord, Stellenbosch, 7613, Republic of South Africa

Disclaimer: Services and products advertised by external product suppliers in this newsletter are paid for by the respective suppliers. Moonstone does not endorse any opinions, conclusions, data, products, services or other information contained in this e-mail which is unrelated to the official business of Moonstone and furthermore accepts no liability in respect of the unauthorised use of its e-mail facility or the sending of e-mail communications for other than strictly business purposes.

The complete disclaimer can be accessed here.
 
©2015 Moonstone. All rights reserved.